Has Arsene Based Arsenal's Transfer Policy On Championship Manager?
With a baffling propensity for buying attacking mids while ignoring the brittle areas of his squad, has Arsene fallen foul of the Championship Manager curse of going attack mental?

So, six AMs will work, no?
With a baffling propensity for buying attacking mids while ignoring the brittle areas of his Arsenal squad, has Arsene fallen foul of the Championship Manager curse of going attack mental?
When I was growing up, my father and I played a lot of Championship Manager. Because we were normal, self-respecting football fans and because Champ Man was brilliant, if occasionally infuriating, fun. From the first ever instalment up to the birth of Football Manager, rarely would an evening go by in our house where one or both of us didn’t spend at least an hour on the current incarnation. Often, we’d both play; one of us hunting for the next Cherno Samba while the other prepared for the following day’s respective school or work, and then swapping over. And sometimes we’d just sit in on the other’s game for a while to see how they were getting on.
I have some fond memories of my dad’s games. I remember him signing a then-unknown James Beattie for his Norwich side, and Beattie going on to score over 50 goals in that season. I vaguely remember Alexander Zickler revelling in a free role in his Bayern Munich side and scoring over 30 goals to secure him the Bundesliga and Champions League double. But the game of his I remember best is one in which he was managing River Plate in Argentina.
Whenever it was, to my great amusement he’d compiled a squad that was completely saturated with attacking midfielders
I think it was just after the halcyon days of the deadly Pablo Aimar/Javier Saviola axis, maybe just creeping into the time where Andres d’Alessandro was the big name there. Whenever it was, to my great amusement he’d compiled a squad that was completely saturated with attacking midfielders. Out of a small group of around 18 players, he had managed to amass 6 or 7 of them, and could come nowhere near fitting them all in his side. A couple of them were versatile enough to play on the wings, AM L/C or AM R/C, and one, the splendidly named Camel Meriem, was a coveted AM/F R/L/C but most were just plain AM C’s and all but one of them sat on the metaphorical bench. When quizzed about his unconventional transfer policy, he wasn’t really sure why he signed so many of them and was as amused as I was about it; as if it was as much a subconscious inclination rather than a concrete decision. In any case, the ‘collection of attacking midfielders’ slipped into Hepburn family lore and became a running joke over the years that we would raise occasionally. I certainly never expected it implemented in real life.
But last week, when my father sent me a text message to say that Arsenal had reacted to their 8-2 defeat at the hands of Manchester United by enquiring about Yossi Benayoun, it struck me that it had indeed come to fruition, and on a fairly grand scale at that. No less than Arsene Wenger had adopted the Brian Hepburn philosophy of football and had begun to collect attacking midfielders with little interest in addressing any of the other deficiencies in his squad.
If you’d asked a cross-section of pundits, neutrals and Gunners fans at the end of last season where they felt Arsenal needed to strengthen to mount a serious title challenge, you would have received a fairly consistent set of answers.
-An experienced goalkeeper to compete with, or succeed, Szczesny.
-An aggressive, dominant centre back to partner Vermaelen.
-A combative ballwinner in the Keane/Vieira mould to anchor their vastly talented midfield.
- A centre forward to provide genuine competition for van Persie, and successfully replace him when he is inevitably injured.
Perhaps there is only one man who would have answered this question with, “Two undeniably talented and highly-promising wingers with no immediate end product”
Perhaps there is only one man who would have answered this question with, “Two undeniably talented and highly-promising wingers with no immediate end product”. That man, however, is Arsene Wenger and his first two signings of the summer were Gervinho and Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain for a total outlay of £22.7m. And, with the exceptions of Carl Jenkinson and Joel Campbell for nominal fees and the return of Ryo Miyaichi from loan, that was it until August 30th. Before the deadline passed, he brought in 5 players, 4 of them direct replacements for players he had allowed to leave; Andre Santos for Gael Clichy, Mikel Arteta for Cesc Fabregas, Yossi Benayoun for Samir Nasri and Park Chu-Young for Nicklas Bendtner; the other being German international centre back Per Mertesacker.
Whether these players represent financially and technically inferior like-for-like replacements is entirely subjective. The more pertinent point is that Wenger saw no reason to address any area of his already-unbalanced squad before the start of the season, other than bringing in an additional two attacking midfielders to complement Theo Walcott, Tomas Rosicky, Andrei Arshavin and Nasri, later Benayoun. And as 4 of the 5 other signings merely filled additional positions that had been vacated over the summer, the only area of weakness he ultimately addressed was in central defence.
In fact, approaches for yet more attacking midfielders, Lucho Gonzalez and Yoann Gourcuff, have been confirmed by Marseille and Lyon club officials in the last week and the club were also recently linked with moves for the mercurial Lille winger Eden Hazard and Sochaux playmaker Marvin Martin. And while it seems likely that the club would have signed two of these ahead of Arteta and Benayoun if possible, the time spent chasing all of these players would undoubtedly have been better spent on securing recruits in more pressing areas for concern. French holding midfielder Yann M’Vila was a major target but a deal could not be concluded before the close of the transfer window; one can’t help but think that a successful resolution would have been more likely had his move been prioritised ahead of Gervinho and Oxlade-Chamberlain’s back in June.
As a result of the transfer activity, Arsenal’s midfield is worryingly imbalanced. Even the bulk of his central midfielders are more inclined towards creativity than disruption; none of Jack Wilshire, Aaron Ramsey or Arteta seem likely to warrant a ‘Tackling’ stat of 10 or more, whereas Abou Diaby is of the box-to-box variety. Alex Song is the only recognised DM C in the squad and Arsenal have already paid the price for their lack of depth in this department. In Song’s absence through suspension, youngster Emanuel Frimpong started the home game against Liverpool and was sent off at 0-0 as they slumped to a 2-0 defeat; in the 8-2 thrashing at Old Trafford, Francis Coquelin deputised alongside Ramsey and Rosicky in the centre of the park as the Gunners failed to contain a rampant United side.
Maybe Arsene is just as unaware that he is neglecting other areas of his squad in favour of AM C’s as my dad was. But ultimately, my father’s stable of flamboyant attackers went on the secure him the Argentine League title and victory in the Copa Libertadores; undoubtedly in highly entertaining fashion. After a well-documented barren spell of 6 years, Wenger will be hailed as a miracle-working visionary if his young Arsenal side secure the equivalent Premiership and Champions League trophies this season. But you and I will know where he got the idea from.
Benayoun? Arteta? Arsene Has Got It Wrong Again
What Would Mario Gotze Have Brought To Arsenal?
Everything You Need To Know About Arsenal’s Per Mertesacker
All Arsene’s Saying, Is Give Park A Chance
Can’t Play, Won’t Spend: The Death Of Arsenal As A Big Club
Arsenal’s Biggest Signing Should Be David Dein
The Filthy Animals Arsenal Need To Be Hard Again
Click here for more Football and Sport stories
Click here to follow Sabotage Times on Twitter
Click here to follow Sabotage Times on Facebook
If you like it, Pass it on
COMMENTS
That's actually a pretty good article, despite my initial skepticism after reading your football manager anecdote. I would suggest however, that Arsene CAN spot a good defensive midfielder. He brought in Vieira after all, whom had been wasting away in AC Milan's reserves. He did also bring in Alex Song and a few years back now, when he went in search of a gifted CDM, he directed his scouts to identify the midfielders who covered the most ground in 90 minutes, a search that brought Flamini to Arsenal. While Flamini wasn't the greatest midfielder to play for the Arsenal, he certainly performed his role. Now Arsenal have Frimpong and, I believe, rather than pay such an extravagant price as that demanded for M'Vila, he chose value in his current squad. While a subjective assessment, I believe Frimpong will mature in the role under Song than he would say, under a scenario where Song & M'Vila shared that role. It may be a mistake. It may prove to be shrewd. He also signed Vermaelen, which surprised everyone at the time - and he's shown he's world class. What is clear is that defensively the stocks have been low for a while and needed bolstering for this season. However, ever the astute man, I believe Wenger figured that rather than wait for Cahill to go on a free transfer, Bolton would drop their ludicrous asking price and deal. They didn't, and Wenger bought Mertsecker. Meanwhile, other clubs had caught a feint smell of desperation surrounding Arsenal, a smell that became more noticeable following the Cesc and Nasri sales. Plus they knew Arsenal had both the cash announced at the beginning of the transfer window, and then the Cesc/Nasri cash. Wenger's dealings (or for some, the lack thereof), while causing frustration in the short-term (and let's not forget causing him huge amounts of stress and pressure), made a clear statement to other clubs: I will not be held for ransom. Furthermore, with a 90k/week cap on player wages enforced on him by the Board, Wenger had little room to negotiate personal terms with players such as Mata against sugar daddy clubs like Chelsea. Remember, he also tried to sign Jones in defense, but Man U offered both a better environment for him (EPL Champions) and undoubtedly, more attractive terms. It is the Board that is the problem, not Wenger - that much I believe will inevitably come out when, in what I hope is the distant future, Wenger leaves Arsenal and published his autobiography. Wenger has sought relief from the Board and to be able to pay his top players competitive salaries. He made this approach in an attempt to retain Nasri and also, should he leave, to be able to sign equivalent - or better - talent to replace him. These approaches were rebuffed. I may be biased, but no other manager of a team in world football (or at least the EPL) with equivalent levels of expectations in terms of top class, big club, competitiveness has operated under a harsher, more restricitve and more difficult environment than Wenger. Add to that the red card and injury woes, and it makes for an environment that even your father would find difficult to navigate on football manager.
You obviously know more about Football Manager than proper football, glad, at least when you are bored playing the game you come out and explain how we should play and how YOU think Arsene is managing is team. I am wondering if in real life you could actually coolect as much silverware than Arsene did and will do. For this poor article you won't get nothing I am afraid, though I will
There is an article knockin' about where wenger explains the reasons for these transfers, saying that he largely looked for PL experience. I do think that the wage demands of individual players are by far the most important factor in any of the signings we made and will make in the foreseeable future - which is understandable. I don't think this unbalances the squad anything like you say. Chamberlain and miyaichi, for example, aren't really proven, reliable players, and I think wenger might just take a chance on them at times this year, so if they work, great, if they don't, no big deal - there's always next year. We have 5 or even 6 CBs (if you count miquel), who we could play, with varying degrees of confidence, but you could say that about the attacking positions - who knows when arshavin will next play well, for example. I think we should have signed another DM, not least because song and frimpong (who I think is going to be fantastic this season) will both be missing for the ACN. Diaby is a competent DM now, actually, but his injuries make him unreliable, and coquelin looks good, but obviously lacks experience. Wenger DID try to address this issue, however, by apparently offering 30m for m'vila, and Lucho could have done the job if we'd signed him - he's not only an attacking midfielder, but actually a box-to-box type player who can do literally everything. Haven't seen him recently, and he's been injured a lot, but a while ago I would have considered him one of the most complete players in world football (that I knew about at the time - not that that counts for much)
like the article, i think wenger still believes that he can pay wages according to campionship manager, as a team when you lose your best players you shoud in theory be planning to bring in equivalant players, but he did not, he said after months of promising, i am happy with the quality of my squad we may not need players then we went to utd got a whitewash, anybody knows kids can not do a mans job they need experience, our defence is suspect to pacy forwards midfield we are so weak, arshavan made the right quote we dont have the players like fab or nasri who can pass to van persie, wenger is dillusional, and i hope by christmas he is gone, we wont finish top 10, and i want to know will this idot board pay back the supporters ticket money as they pay the most in gate tickets than any club in europe to watch this mediocore team, the players we have , are not prem players we lack desperatly midfield, and attack


RELATED








SABOTAGE





